Skip to main content
IT BIBLESign in

Forum / Networking / Routers & Switches

Is LTE failover worth it over a spare modem?

RackGhostDwayne OP
#1

The question: when does a small office with one ISP line actually need a second WAN link on the router, and is LTE failover worth the extra complexity compared to a spare modem on the shelf? I have a lean, but I would like to compare it with yours.

My lean is that the answer depends on what an hour of downtime costs, not on how clever the setup is. Most of the outages I have seen were not the ISP's core network. They were a dead modem, a bad drop, or a line that the provider took four hours to look at. A spare modem fixes the first one in ten minutes. It does nothing for a cut line down the street. Think of keeping a spare tire when the road itself is closed.

The cost side of LTE failover is real, and people leave it out:

  1. Two gateways means the router has to decide when the primary is dead. That means a monitor, usually pinging something past the modem, and the wrong target gives false failovers.
  2. Existing connections break when the path switches, because the public IP changes. VPN tunnels have to rebuild. Anything that hairpins to a fixed address will complain.
  3. Cellular behind carrier NAT often has no inbound reachability at all, so a port forward or a phone system that needs one will not come back.
  4. Data caps. A backup that quietly pulls a backup job over a metered link is a bad surprise.

On OPNsense this is a gateway group with tiered priority, and it works fine. But I would not call it set-and-forget until you have pulled the primary cable on purpose and watched what breaks. And I do not remember every menu, so check your own version.

For an office that can live with half a day of downtime, I lean toward the spare modem plus a written note on who calls whom. For one that cannot, I lean toward LTE, tested twice a year.

Where do you draw the line? And has anyone had a failover that actually fired when it was needed, with nobody touching it?

Sign in to reply.