The question: how do you tell a bad punch-down at the patch panel from a bad cable when a run beats a cheap continuity tester but the link only negotiates 100 Mbps? I have a method, but I would like to compare it with yours.
The background is simple. A basement run, about 40 feet, Cat5e, terminated at a keystone in a panel and at a wall jack. The tester lights all eight pins in order. Both ends still come up at 100 Mbps full duplex, never gigabit.
A continuity tester only proves that each pin reaches the far end. It says nothing about pair twist, a split pair, or a conductor that is touching the contact but not seated well. Gigabit uses all four pairs at once. 100 Mbps uses only two, pins 1, 2, 3 and 6. So a link that settles at 100 is often telling you that the orange and green pairs work and the blue or brown pair does not.
My order of work:
- Check the physical layer first. Swap the patch cords at both ends for known good ones. Cords fail more than people admit.
- Look at which pairs are in trouble. Pins 4, 5, 7 and 8 are the usual suspects.
- Re-punch the blue and brown pairs at the panel. Keep the untwist under half an inch, and use a fresh punch-down blade, since a worn one leaves a conductor half seated.
- If it is still at 100, put a short known good cable in place of the whole run, and see if the port negotiates 1000. That separates the switch and NIC from the wiring.
A tester that reports pair length or cable faults would settle this faster. I have not used the mid-priced ones enough to recommend a model, and they cost real money for something you may use twice a year.
What do you reach for first, the punch tool or the cable tester? And has anyone had a run that looked clean and still failed because of a bad keystone jack and not the punch-down?